HeroSite banner
Home Blogs Episodes Guide Gallery Spoilers Real Heroes Forums Other Sites

« 2.06 "The Line" | Main | 2.08 "Four Months Ago" »

2.07 "Out of Time"

Overview:

West makes waffles for Claire, then freaks out after learning that his abductor is Claire's father. Hiro blows up White Beard's camp (and Kensei), bids Yaeko goodbye, and goes back to the future. Peter meets Angela in a post-apocalyptic world in which 93% of the population have been killed off by the Shanti virus. Caitlin gets deported, and Peter inadvertently teleports back to Montreal, where we learn that Adam is Kensei. Maury visits Company Medical and manipulates Niki into going on a Jessica-style rampage. Niki breaks free of this control by injecting herself with the Shanti virus, which is quite tragic because Mohinder's blood can't cure this variant of the virus. Maury's out of the picture, though, because Matt puts him in his own super-coma after helping Molly wake up from hers. And, yes, I know that's longer than the usual overview. Sue me. A lot happened in this episode.

Review:

Previously on Heroes: there were a bunch of episodes which introduced characters who were nice and all, but whose storylines weren't particularly compelling.

This week on Heroes: most of the newbies get benched, the subplots for two of the central characters wrap up, the old characters come together again, and it's all pretty awesome.

You don't think there could be a connection, do you?

Greg Beeman does!

"I know that many fans will be happy that this one brings many of last year's characters together again. This episode also concludes Peter's story in Ireland and has Hiro leaving feudal Japan to return to the present..."

Then, color me stunned, Tim Kring this week addressed fan complaints and admitted that his show "took too long to get to the big-picture story," and that the next volume would focus on "doing something about it."

Which is staggeringly humble and honest of the guy, but which, on the strength of this episode alone, seems like a resolution he'll be able to keep. Because, minor complaints aside, this episode was quite simply phenomenal.

We open in the Land of Sark, where Hiro's pretty dopey from being held over a pot of opium. Cool detail. At least someone thought up a foil for Hiro's abilities. Otherwise, we'd be asking why Hiro doesn't freeze time, free himself from restraints, remove Yaeko and Papa Swordsmith to a distant hilltop, behead White Beard, bury the stockpile of guns which the army amassed, then teleport Kensei to the middle of a field and give him a stern ta-

Oh. Wait. He does get a chance to do some of that...

Ah, never mind. The pot of opium was still a cool detail.

Kensei calls Yaeko "my love," with quote marks in the subtitles. Neat touch. The way he looks at her in this scene, I still struggle to believe he ever cared about her enough to be so angry, but details like that at least embellish the bitterness.

Kensei's going to get half the country -- and Yaeko -- if he hands Hiro over to White Beard. So, only half the country will be painted in different shades of green and covered in purple flags? I'm not sure which half I should feel sorry for.

More relevantly, what would White Beard want with Hiro when he can coerce Kensei? As far as White Beard knows, it's Kensei with the ability to make swords disappear, disrobe the 12 Stupid Samurai, slaughter 90 cannibal warriors, and rescue a swordsmith from the center of White Beard's army. You can imagine how difficult it would have been for Kensei to convince White Beard that Hiro was the one with the ability he wanted.

"But it's not me with the special ability you want, it's Hiro!"

[White Beard stabs Kensei through the gut. Kensei heals.]

"Yeah, OK, that's a cool party trick. But Hiro can make people's clothes disappear!"

[White Beard gouges Kensei's eyes out. They grow back.]

"Oh, fine, so I can do some neat s**t too. But, look, TRUST ME, Hiro's the one you want to coerce into doing your evil bidding."

[White Beard castrates Kensei. Kensei's organs immediately regenerate.]

"Good point, well made. Who cares about teleportation when you can do that."

Kensei: "I will be the greatest leader Japan has ever known. I will change history."

Great delivery by David Anders. I still don't buy the idea that Hiro's babbling -- or even Yaeko -- would change Kensei from a drunken, aimless coward to a decisive, power-hungry leader; but Anders gets props for the way he changes the character's whole demeanor this week: the level stare, the confident swagger, the authoritative tone. It makes the Adam reveal all the more believable. As per last week, if you can forgive the flimsy rationale behind it, it's a blast to watch.

CG Ukraine. Less CG now because it's just a warehouse.

I love how Noah enunciates "a g-u-n" to Mohinder like he's an imbecile. If Mohinder's worried that Niki will inspect his cell phone for picture messaging then Noah's probably not far off, but this scene reaffirmed once again that Noah doesn't really trust anyone, and that Mohinder was never really an equal partner in the plot to overthrow The Company. I'm not even sure Noah trusts the Haitian. As far as we know, there still hasn't been a serious conversation about the whole reporting-to-Mrs.-Petrelli-over-Noah's-head issue.

I feel pretty bad for Mohinder here. Between The Company's shady agenda and Molly's illness and Noah apparently not caring if Mohinder's in danger, the guy blatantly has no idea who to turn to or who to trust. And as much as people decried Mohinder's stupidity for coming clean with Bob this week, this exchange between Mohinder and Noah set up why Mohinder felt he had nothing to lose by ending the charade.

Noah striking the match on the ground and setting fire to the paintings? That's awesome. The flames from the fire reflected in Noah's glasses, though? That's doubly awesome.

Matt and Nathan show up at Company Medical to get Bob to safety. How did they know where to find Bob? Who knows. Who cares? This reunion is so amazing that you can forgive anything.

normal_062.jpg

Look at that wistful gaze between Matt and Mohinder. This is a great moment for Matthinder fans.

normal_063.jpg

"Yeah, baby. That night really did cost me 7,973 bucks. And it was worth every cent."

If we had a scene like this every week, it would probably lose its appeal. But does the show realize how much of a kick we got out of it? This scene crackled with energy, and I can't help wondering if we'll ever get something like that out of a meeting between Maya, Monica, and Elle, even a season from now.

And that's if they all survive that long. Which they probably won't.

The newer characters lack the gravitas of the original characters, and their on-screen chemistry is unlikely to match what we're looking at in this scene. Is that a failure on the show's part? It could be. Or it could be that we're unwilling to embrace new characters because we love the original ones too much and can't bear to see them marginalized or written out in favor of new ones.

More obviously, it's an enormous obstacle when it comes to introducing new characters, especially when the biggest complaint from fans about the new season is that it spends too much time with new characters whose stories have failed to captivate the audience the way the original characters' storylines managed to last season. It means that new characters are constantly going to suffer from having their story, charisma, and chemistry with other characters compared with the original characters'.

Future NY. Also less CG than last week. I totally fell for the landmark buildings in the background and wondered if the scene itself was shot in New York and the Peter/Caitlin portion was green-screened into it.

The armored vehicle pulls up, the Hazmat guys rush out and pin Peter and Caitlin to the ground, and it's as if the whole meandering chronicle of iPods and soccer bets and Identity Boxes and Irish mobster ringleaders never happened. This is the kind of storyline we waited a quarter of a season for; something epic; something which puts one of the central characters in jeopardy; something which ties Peter's thread to the overarching story arc for the volume.

And a GREEN ECLIPSE. Too cool.

Canine Central. Before we get to the waffles, I need to point out how incredible this week's title card was: the letters expand as Claire's pillow bounces back into shape. Whoever came up with that effect -- it rocks.

OK, so West visits Claire before she wakes up, introduces himself to Sandra, ingratiates himself with the family by feeding and playing with Mr. Muggles, then texts Claire to let her know he's downstairs.

Is this behavior:

(a) presumptuous, brazen, arrogant, rude, etc.

(b) just plain creepy,

(c) thoughtful, and kind of sweet,

(d) a valiant attempt to assuage Papa Butler's aversion to all of Claire's boyfriends until she turns 21.

Do take a moment to put the situation into its relevant context:

normal_102.jpg

Sandra doesn't look that peeved for the rest of the scene, although West does kind of look that smug the entire time. But Sandra seems to be waiting for the guy to sprout wings and pull out a harp, so at least part of the plan worked. And, you know, I'm still holding onto the theory that West is a Company plant, meaning this was just the latest stage in his effort to fracture the family and alienate Claire from her parents.

But to get back to the point, was this a sweet gesture? As much as I hate West, the guy actually asks if "Mr. Butler" will be joining them. And even though he's nervous about it, I grudgingly have to credit West for walking into the lion's den and trying to make a good impression. In a story thread defined by interminable Secrets & Lies garbage, this seemed like an effort on West's part to please Claire's parents, to do something thoughtful for Claire, and to end the sneaking around.

Alternatively, it was presumptuous, brazen, arrogant, rude, etc. And just plain creepy. You decide.

West shows Claire the newspaper article.

normal_107.jpg

^ ^ Not a real article!

"Postponement of substantive debate may require implementation to encourage individual conference time and availability"?

Oh, come on. You call that a nod to obsessive fans? You guys got Mark Harelik on the show! And you've already got D'Agosto! At least get the guy from the props department on Election who used a newspaper article in the movie to ask if we realized what a thankless task it is to write fake newspaper articles, and to wonder what kind of people freeze the frame to read them.

Dude, have you met the people who watch this show?

The Midas Study. Bob's cello is still there!

Mohinder: "Isn't this all a bit reactionary?"

Well, it would be, if Maury was after Nathan because he planned to overhaul New York's political system. But I think Mohinder meant to ask if this wasn't all a bit of an overreaction.

Papa Parkman is named on-screen as Maury. I don't like it as much as Papa Parkman, but I'll run with it.

Matt plans to take Bob into custody to protect him from Maury. This earns Matt a

PING!

Dumb As Parkman Award, because I can't believe his memory's so bad he'd forget what happened to the last ElderSuper he took into custody.

This does, however, raise the question of Maury's proximity to the victim. He gave Molly nightmares and put her in a coma all the way from Philadelphia. Was he at the police station where Angela was held, or did he scare the life out of her from his apartment? And if he doesn't need to be within a certain distance of his victims in order to get inside their heads, WHAT THE HELL IS HE DOING HERE? The plan was very clearly to use the people surrounding Bob to kill him. If that's the case, Maury could pretty much have gone back to his apartment and curled up on the couch while this whole thing went down.

Bob uses the same dialogue Linderman used last season. Nathan immediately zeroes in on it. Great nod to continuity, and to showing how the ElderSupers think alike, even if their methods differ. It also shows up rather elegantly how observant and perceptive Nathan is when it comes to speech, which is a big plus in the character consistency column for a guy whose career used to depend on using the right words at the right time. Well played, writers.

Bob tries to convince Mohinder that injecting Maury with the virus is the only way to prevent him from using Mohinder's worst nightmares against him. This made me wonder what Mohinder's worst nightmares might be. Probably going on a roadtrip with a psycho-killer, or behaving like a deranged madman, or possibly having his family's legacy relegated to a shelf between hypnosis and alien abduction.

Land of Sark. The tents are red in real life. And the guard's hat is pointy. I hope Yaeko's paying attention to this for future reference.

Papa Swordsmith laments making the guns. LazyGuard finds these laments boring and walks off. It's convenient for the story, because now Yaeko can use her hairpin to pick the lock on her chains.

Yaeko: "They always underestimate women. Their folly."

I hope one day Yaeko can forgive us, for we have underestimated her resourcefulness and doubted her perfection. She is, after all, the one who kissed Hiro and sent Kensei on a 300-year vendetta. She is, after all, the one who painted pictures while her father was coerced into supplying stockpiles of guns so that his daughter would be safe. And she is, after all, the one who now helps Hiro to teleport both of them away from the camp, and presumably Papa Swordsmith too. Problem is, Papa Swordsmith was on the other side of the tent and still chained up when Hiro and Yaeko teleported out of there. And he isn't on the hilltop where Hiro and Yaeko appear. And he isn't in the tent when the guard returns.

So the creator of Kensei's legendary sword is now AWOL. Bummer.

Future NY. Peter and Caitlin get hosed.

It's not every day I get to write a line like that.

Peter's clearly scared out of his wits and anxious to make sure Caitlin's OK, so why the CDC workers aren't collecting their severed, electrified limbs from every corner of the warehouse escapes me. But this whole Virus Future timeline is so disturbing that nothing could pull me out of it.

Peter's forced to park his butt at the L-Q table. And every table has a wastepaper basket next to it. And there are spare water tanks next to the cooler. That kills me. All of the details in this storyline were flawless: color, tone, lighting, props, even the grit and the dirt. Top to bottom, this whole storyline rocked my world.

The guy in charge of shoveling the body bags shows up, and it's Mark Harelik. Awesome.

Peter gets a tour of the warehouse, and we learn that the Shanti Virus mutated and crossed over into the general population just as Bob feared it would.

normal_182.jpg

Is that CG? Probably. It's probably the same as the offices at Yamagato. But if it is, I can't tell. And it's convincing enough to scare the bejesus out of Peter. Now he really won't sleep for two months.

Company Medical. Matt sits at Molly's bedside.

Matt: "I'm supposed to be out hunting Maury, but I needed to see you."

I know I could rip this apart; if he'd only found Maury sooner, Niki might not have needed to inject herself with the virus. But you know what? Greg Grunberg was so great in this scene that I almost don't care. The guy gets tears in his eyes. Not the Hayden cry-on-demand kind, but the I'm-trying-to-hold-it-together kind. When he's telling Molly how he thought his dad left because he was too slow and fat and stupid, you feel for the guy. Grunberg puts across a sense of shame and regret without turning it into a whole pity-me-because-my-daddy-left-me performance. It's moving drama without devolving into melodrama.

How To Make The Male Cast Hotter In Season Two: Baring your soul and elaborating on a lifetime of self-esteem issues to the comatose kid you think of as a daughter. Grunberg doesn't get a lot of scenes to shine on this show, but this is one of them.

Mohinder describes Bob as "morally gray," which is another subtle echo of dialogue used in a different context. I don't know if that implies that Bob's the new Company Man who'll turn out to have a heart of gold, but if Elle is his daughter, and if he is using objectionable methods to achieve a noble goal, the parallels to Noah are going to become even more overt.

The Midas Study contains seven volumes on Angela? Imagine that. Seven volumes on her badass punk-rock days. What I wouldn't give to read those.

Nathan asks Bob to "uncomplicate" the situation with Adam Monroe, and we get yet another rendition of, "We were lost, but we came together; we thought we could save the world, but some of us were lunatics, so it didn't work out." And it still sounds great, even after it's been recounted by Linderman, by Papa Sulu, by Maury, and by Bob.

I'll sound like a broken record if I say it again, but I really, really wish a volume with the title "GENERATIONS," a volume which was supposedly going to involve the sins of the parents being revisited on the children, could give this backstory a little more detail. The Shanti Virus is obviously a key part of it, but I can't help thinking that the whole story deserves more attention than it's getting.

"Snow Falls in Miami" could have read "Tsunami wipes out Eastern Seaboard." Intriguing. Is that because there was a crazy weather-blessed super out there and The Company stopped him? Or because there was going to be a natural disaster and one of the ElderSupers used their ability to avert it? It's fascinating either way. More on this, please.

Bob recounts how Adam started to think of himself as a god, and how he started to talk about holocausts and plagues and punishing humanity. And I know I wasn't supposed to attribute this to West's remark last week about an ability making someone better than everyone else, but I couldn't help wondering; if you gave West another 10 years as an outcast and a loner, and if the guy spent all that time floating above town, mocking the population the way he did in the graphic novel for being too closed-minded to look up, wouldn't he end up thinking this way too?

Nah. He makes waffles for his girlfriend.

So, Adam and Linderman were one faction of The ElderSupers. And Angela was clearly on their team most of the time. And Papa Sulu and Papa Deveaux were apparently the non-believers who wanted to uphold a non-lunatic approach to "making a difference." I'm going to go out on a limb and say Bob's closer to these guys than the Adam faction. Maury seems like the kind of ideological sheep who'll be swayed into doing what anyone wants. (I don't want to say Matt's the same way, but given the way things turn out in at least one timeline, it doesn't bode well.) And Papa Petrelli and the rest of the ElderSupers have yet to be characterized.

Beeman? Kring? You guys still listening to fans complaining? I want you to ask yourself whether the drama from these characters and this story wouldn't have been about fifty trillion times more compelling than a super who cries black goo, a b**chy cheerleader who gets her comeuppance, and a princess in feudal Japan who paints purple flags. Because, good God.

At least we're moving in the right direction this week.

Hilariously, you'll note that Bob spent this entire scene looking away from the video surveillance footage he was supposed to be watching in case Maury showed up.

Future NY. Angela visits the warehouse to smack some sense into her boy so that he'll go back in time to prevent the outbreak of the Shanti Virus.

And even in a bleak, post-apocalyptic future, Angela's STILL WEARING FANCY EARRINGS.

You have to feel for her here. Even though she's the Ice Queen. And even though she lied to her boys. And even though she stole socks. And even though she arranged faux-brunches to fool the press. And even though she basically kidnapped Claire. And even though she slept with Papa Sulu. And even though she orchestrated a scheme in which her son exploded and leveled a city and killed millions of people.

... In spite of all that, can we STILL feel sorry for Angela when one son dies and another gets amnesia?

You can't tell me that doesn't say something about Cristine Rose. If the actress can make a character sympathetic in spite of all of that, she doesn't need a superpower on the show. She has a pretty amazing one in real life.

But here's the moment which sparked off an extensive debate on the nature of Angela's ability: did Peter's memories come back of their own accord, or did Angela restore them? I'd say it was mostly just meeting a familiar face and hearing her voice which restored Peter's memories of his mom. But I can also totally see Angela's ability being a counterbalance to the Haitian's mindwipe, or the ability to climb into people's heads and mess around with their synaptic pathways or something.

More interesting to me is the way Angela's now making a full-time job out of using both of her sons as tools. First using one son as a springboard for political influence, then using another as a catalyst to unite humanity through grief, then using that same son a year later to go back in time to fix a mistake which, in all likelihood, her circle of deluded supers probably brought about in the first place. It's not like Angela isn't right to ask Peter to alter history to prevent a global epidemic, but it's also kind of shocking how she manipulates her sons at the same time as caring so much about them.

Anyway, we cut from that to Mr. Muggles on the couch, watching Claire and West making out. Poor Lestat. And I say that as one of Hayden's biggest fans.

Claire's about to tell West that her father's the man who turned him into a lab rat, but West preempts the discussion by telling Claire they won't "go any further" if she doesn't want to. Which again earns West a little credit, because even if the first conclusion he reaches is that Claire wants to discuss sex -- probably because it's the only thing HE'S thinking of -- he still comes out of this looking like the patient, understanding boyfriend.

Problem is, it's not what she was going to say, and it signals rather obviously that West doesn't understand Claire and has no inkling of what's bothering her.

And, in spite of a couple of redeeming moments for West in this episode, NOTHING could be more satisfying than this. Behold:

normal_319.jpg

Now THAT, my friends, is a prank.

THAT is comeuppance.

THAT is "a lesson in humility."

Noah gets West's popsicle. I don't know if that's supposed to be ironic or if I'm just reading the irony into it. Truthfully, I don't care. West haters, rejoice!

Land of Sark. Yaeko tries to placate Hiro, like, "White Beard won. Meh, s**t happens. Don't feel bad. You're a nerd who quotes comic books and messes around with time -- what can you do to stop an army and an invincible guy?" And Hiro's all, "Baby, he's gone to the Dark Side, BUT I CAN BRING HIM BACK!"

Hiro teleports to the tent where White Beard keeps a dozen kegs of gunpowder. Kensei shows up, and we get a

SWOOOOOOOOORDFIGHT!

It's no Anakin/Obi-Wan duel-to-the-death masterpiece, but as TV budgets and choreographing go, it's about as spectacular as you could hope for. It's also an extremely subtle way to make use of Hiro's training with Papa Sulu, because it allows for a swordfight that's fairly evenly matched.

Kensei: "As long as I have breath, anything you love, I will lay to waste."

He is SO the one who killed Papa Sulu. I'm now worried for Kimiko, Ando, and the cast of every incarnation of Star Trek.

The exploding tent was off-the-charts stellar. As stunts go, it's one of the best the show has produced. How we went from clunky flying sequences and computerized Angry Ronin to this is beyond me, but this absolutely rocked.

Company Medical. Maury uses an image of D.L. to tell Niki she's crazy and going to kill everyone.

The cameo from Leonard Roberts is a delight, even if it's brief, and even if he's really just saying what Maury wants him to say instead of what D.L. would actually say. I'm surprised Niki's worst nightmare doesn't involve Micah a little more; maybe an image of Micah getting shot would have been too much, for the character and for the show when it came to having a pseudo-morally-gray-hero shoot a kid. But even if the show didn't want to tempt the FCC like that, you'd think an apparition of Micah watching his dad die would be the fastest way to manipulate Niki.

Bob AGAIN ditches the video surveillance, this time to pull up footage of Peter being treated at Company Medical after exploding over New York.

Let me get this straight: Bob knew Peter was alive and Angela didn't? What happened? Did Bob expel her from the inner circle after Linderman died? Is she totally out of the loop when it comes to Company operations?

Niki shows up outside the Midas Study and goes postal on the door, which is both terrifying and formidable, and lends credence to Yaeko's observation that "they always underestimate women." I'd love to know how Maury immediately knew Niki was the one he'd use to kill Bob. Was it just the snippet of dialogue he heard in the corridor about brutally ripping people in half?

Niki realizes she's being controlled by Maury and injects herself with the Shanti virus. We get the obligatory single tear.

normal_435.jpg

But as with Matt's scene at Molly's bedside, it doesn't feel unnecessarily overplayed or melodramatic. Maya's more Niki-like than Niki is these days. Unlike Maya crying at every available opportunity, this moment seemed less like arbitrary hysteria and more like an impossible decision which Niki was forced to make in the heat of the moment. The fact that Niki chose to endanger herself rather than let out the killer she became because of Jessica adds to her nobility.

Meanwhile, Matt -- who was supposed to track down Maury BEFORE he had a chance to channel anyone's worst nightmare -- is taking a nap. He's woken by the sound of someone breaking a door down, and finds himself in a vision of the apartment he lived in when Maury walked out on him. Once again, kudos to the team building the sets, because, as with Maury's apartment, this absolutely nailed the character and the mood. The faded green and yellow wallpaper and cupboards and the cheap furniture and the harsh lighting bring the mood to life; they all evoke the idea of a family that was trying to maintain a sense of cheeriness, but which knew deep down that there was something inherently corrupt in it.

Matt hauls his dad into the same vision, and it's gotten so confusing that I can't figure out who's standing in the corridor at Company Medical and still awake, who's asleep and dreaming, who's in a coma, and who's actually in this apartment right now. It's bizarre.

Maury tells Matt that it broke his heart to abandon his family. He seems to mean it, so as much as I'd like to write the guy off as a monster, I'm tempted to think the show will pull a Bennet and explain why Maury made impossible decisions for some greater good. It could be that Maury was the one who stopped Weather-Super from creating a tsunami which wiped out the Eastern Seaboard. Again, something I would have loved to see in this volume.

Grunberg steals this scene. When Matt's shouting back at Maury that he's a good man, you want to cheer for him. Even though he stole. Even though he deceived his wife. Even though he forced his foster daughter to confront her worst nightmare.

And when he tells Maury that he's a good cop, you again want to cheer for him. Even though he assaulted a fellow officer. Even though he only got a detective job by cheating. Even though he used his gun to take a family hostage.

And when he tells Maury that he's a good father, you still want to cheer for him. Even though you're not completely sure which kid he's talking about -- the one he left with Janice, or Molly. And if he's talking about Molly, hey, putting the kid in a coma was for the greater good! Sort of.

What!? I still think he's right! And Grunberg still knocks this scene out of the park, even if it's a bit of a generalization to say Matt's a good man and a good cop and a good father.

Matt realizes that Maury's standing in his own nightmare, and locks his dad in a super-coma. Molly immediately wakes up and embraces Matt, and all is right with the world.

Except Matt's daddy issues are now probably about ten times worse.

And Molly doesn't even say "I love you too" when Matt tells her he loves her? Mohinder is most definitely her favorite daddy.

Mohinder gives Niki a transfusion, even after she broke his nose. And she apologizes with this little half-smile. And Mohinder smiles. And it's beautiful.

normal_542.jpg

normal_541.jpg

OH, COME ON. IT'S MEANT TO BE!

Or not. Because Bob's gone and created some kind of industrial strength variant of the virus which Mohinder's blood can't cure. And Niki realizes she's going to die. I defy ANYONE to watch this and not be bowled over by Ali Larter's performance. When she realizes she's going to die, there's not a hint of self-pity or anxiety in her voice. It's resignation and realization that she won't be able to take care of Micah once she's gone. Ali Larter is a goddess. I don't know how this show made an episode with such a perfect balance between pyrotechnics and dramatic reveals and character-oriented gems like this, but this episode achieved it in spades.

And if they kill Niki, I'm really going to be p**sed. Although less so than if they kill Noah.

Mohinder gets the g-u-n. He learns from Bob that one possible cure for Niki's terminal virus might be Noah's daughter.

The one who Noah apparently never told Mohinder about.

The one who Matt apparently never told Mohinder about, even though he shot her.

Does anyone ever tell Mohinder ANYTHING? No wonder the guy earned the first Dumb As Award of the series. No wonder he ends up making bad decisions. He's got absolutely nothing to work with.

Is Mohinder wrong to admit to Bob everything about his plot with Noah? I'd say no, mostly because Mohinder realized at this point that trusting Bob might save Niki's life, and that he no longer had any reason to trust Noah. It's not like Bob's any more trustworthy, but he hasn't put holes in anyone's head as far as Mohinder knows, and for the most part, he's been open with Mohinder about the reason The Company wants to research the virus, and why it captures and tests individuals.

On a selfish level, part of it's probably that The Company seems to value Mohinder a lot more than Noah did. On a broader level, it also seems like The Company's goals, at least under Bob's tenure, are benign. If Noah's plan to dismantle The Company ended up undermining an effort to save a super's life from a terminal illness, I can easily buy into the idea that Mohinder would admit there's a rogue ex-employee trying to thwart what they're doing.

Now, all of that said, I can't wait to see how the tables are turned when Adam sells an even more convincing story to Peter than Bob has to Mohinder.

Land of Sark. Hiro retrieves Kensei's helmet from the rubble and teleports back to Yaeko. Yaeko displays no sadness over Kensei's demise -- despite the fact that Kensei was at least partly responsible for locating White Beard's army and rescuing Yaeko's father -- and expresses no grief over the notion that her infidelity very nearly rewrote 300 years of history.

You have to love this character.

Yaeko places enormous confidence in her ability to trumpet Kensei's heroism. It seems this will overcome all eyewitness accounts of the man who could be found in a drunken stupor and who was willing to pay anyone willing to dress up and parade the name "Kensei" in battle.

I guess the heroic version of the story is more appealing than the real one, and that's why it survived. But it's also a fortunate turn of events that Hiro could return to the future and not worry about Kensei immediately showing up to slit Yaeko's throat and prevent her from ever saying anything about Kensei's heroic deeds.

Hiro: "I must go back."

Oh, no. Not again. Please, show, NOT AGAIN. Don't get my hopes high if he's going to stick around for another four episodes.

We get another scene where Masi takes a valiant shot at bringing this romance to life. Props to the actor. Even Eriko Tamura's OK here. As with everything relating to Kensei's switch from money-obsessed drunkard to scorned-and-embittered warrior, if you can forget everything leading up to it, it's beautifully written and beautifully shot and beautifully acted.

If you put it into the context of a weak-ass storyline, it's less appealing. So I'm going to pretend Hiro whisked Yaeko six months into the past, that they had a delightful love affair before this whole situation with Kensei even began, that Hiro folded a thousand origami cranes for Yaeko, that he begged her to elope with him, that she refused for the sake of history, and that everything that happened here was staged to ensure that history recorded the Kensei legend as it was supposed to. That way, Hiro and Yaeko's hearts really would be broken when they said goodbye, and the romance between them really would resonate the way it was intended do.

Yes, I am indeed TOTALLY ripping off a romance we've seen on this show before. Because, so far, it's the one romance the show got right.

Yamagato Empire. Ando's actually working. Isn't this sort of sad? I mean, he's throwing himself into his work, dedicating himself to his career; then Hiro shows up, and Ando will go back to watching online strippers on his iPod and taking unauthorized leave and playing video games on his PC.

But look ...

normal_549.jpg

And look ...

normal_554.jpg

They're so pleased! And WE'RE SO PLEASED! The feudal Japan story is finally over!

Then Ando goes and kills the moment by telling Hiro about Papa Sulu's death. At least he's honest and doesn't try to break the news to Hiro slowly or easily. That's a true friend. Unlike, say, someone who locks lips with your girlfriend and pretends to be cheerful and upbeat the next time he sees you.

Gah! I'm going to need until at least the end of this volume to put the whole storyline behind me.

It gets even better. At Canine Central, the Secrets & Lies blow up in everyone's face. Noah calls Claire on the bratty rebellious streak. Claire calls Noah on the fake business trips which nobody's falling for. Sandra scowls. And Lyle gets told to shut up after one line of dialogue. And Noah wants the family to relocate. And even though it was obvious it would be Claire's fault that the family needed to move house again, I'd like to point out that I, like many, called it way back when Claire was burning her hand over Bunsen burners and clipping off her pinky toe.

Montreal Junk Room. Peter teleports back after watching Caitlin get shipped out of the U.S., and meets Adam, who we immediately recognize as Kensei, although Anders is now playing the character less as a jilted lover and more as a warped and supremely overconfident supervillain. Which, more than ever, underlines how wasted the actor's talents were in the feudal Japan story.

Even if you knew who Adam was, the way the introduction was done was so out of this world that none of the impact was lost. Catching the electric bolt and letting his fried hand heal? Does the guy even feel that, or is his tolerance for pain even higher than Claire's after 300 years of injury? It was unbelievably cool. I mean, I was spoiled about Adam's identity, and this was STILL the single coolest moment of the season.

And it's one moment in an ocean of amazing moments contained in this episode. There were some outstanding performances from Grunberg and Cristine Rose, some exceptional visual effects, and some of the best set work the show has achieved since it started.

Above all, this episode reminded us how well the show can be written. It's been a while since we got an episode in which every scene counted, and in which every line of dialogue served a purpose and sparkled. It used to be the case on this show every week, but this was the first episode of the season which achieved that.

Let's hope it's the first of many.

4.5 out of 5

Comments (17)

Jay:

This in my opinion was the best episode of series 2 so far.



Andrew:

Chops to Beeman for admitting some of the flaws in the season thus far, and lets hope this was a start of better things. Sadly, next weeks episode going back four months looks like it'll bring back the toxic twins. To give Hiro credit on ditching "his great love" in the past to face Kensei's revenge, it looked like Kensei was shredded fairly thoroughly when the gunpowder blew up. We know that Claire regenerates, rather than reconstitutes from having body parts re-attached, I assume it took a LONG time to grow back a body. Maybe a couple centuries?



Raissa:

This ep. was definitely the best of the season in and of itself, but that still doesn't change the fact that all it did was minimize the pre-existing story damage in context. S2 will be the season of really cool moments and performances; the overall flow and coherence still make me want to weep.

Re: Mohinder -- Putting the context aside, I for one reacted to his spilling everything to Bob, because of previous spy show experience. Double agents should never cop to being double agents; it's just not a good long-term survival strategy.



Henrik:

This does, however, raise the question of Maury's proximity to the victim. He gave Molly nightmares and put her in a coma all the way from Philadelphia. Was he at the police station where Angela was held, or did he scare the life out of her from his apartment? And if he doesn't need to be within a certain distance of his victims in order to get inside their heads, WHAT THE HELL IS HE DOING HERE? The plan was very clearly to use the people surrounding Bob to kill him. If that's the case, Maury could pretty much have gone back to his apartment and curled up on the couch while this whole thing went down.

It might be that he has be in a certain range of the victims, but he can scare Molly from a great distance because of Molly power. Maybe they have a kind of connection because of it?

By the way, this really was the first real Heroes since "How to stop an exploding man". I really don't get why people didn't like the finale. Since this episode was so awesome, there's hope that Heroes has returned to its old ways..



Daniel P:

Whew. What an episode. Definitely the greatest of season 2, and I would say it's as good as Homecoming.

It's a shame that people hate the Maya/Alejandro storyline so much. Much in part due to the fact that the characters themselves are very interesting ones that were thrown into a currently disconnected and decreasingly compelling storyline.



Brandon:

I was under the impression that Peter regaining memories of his mother was the work of his (Matt's) mind-reading ability.

"Peter, you need to remember", the last line before all those Angela flashbacks, had that tell-tale echo that implies a mental thought in the show.



Michael:

Regarding why Maury chose Niki, remember that Maury can read minds. He probably scanned everyone's mind (except Matt's) without them realizing it.
As for Matt not hunting down Maury, he was supposed to use his powers to stop Maury. Unfortunately, he had no idea how to do so. It's amazing he figured it out at the last minute.
I don't think that Maury is "morally grey". He abandoned his son, put his son's foster daughter into a coma and apparently partnered himself with a man who wants to kill 93% of the planet's population.



tree1138:

I definitively think this was one of the best episodes of this season. Aside from that, the plot device of going into the future and revisiting what happened x months before the story started, might start to seem redundant if it is used to often. Thankfully this issue was avoided by only having Peter's story line be in the future. Besides that, is anyone else upset by the way Caitlin was left? I strongly suspected this would be her last episode, but I hope her storyline is resolved and she isn't dropped without much further mention.
In the future did anyone else find it a bit odd that all of the citizens in the warehouse were wearing white cotton looking clothes? Also, going by the episode and the graphic novel "Quarantine" it said the virus had spread through out the world. Do you think it is meant that since it is a "super" virus that it could spread over "super" distances; or like the scenario in the SG-1 season 9 episode "The Fourth Horseman" where people don't know they are infected, so they get on one of today's various long distance transports. I know those are trivial pondering but so what.
Looking forwards, I hope the writers strike won't end Heroes before it can come back, since now it really is getting good.



Daniel P:

I'm loving the new pictures. It adds a lot. Did it happen to have anything to do with the review delay? Just curious. My Thursday felt empty.



KellyH:

Yes, this episode was up there with the best of S1, but since critics and others have already been trumpeting hackneyed clichés like "shark jumping" and "sophomore slump," I wonder if many of them even noticed, especially with the strike dominating all TV news. TV Guide's Matt Roush, who usually always responds to a great "Heroes" ep, had nothing to say. Funny thing is, Episode 3 was the only REALLY poor one...

Depressingly, Katie Carr is not listed in the guest cast for the next three episodes. I can't believe Peter would strand her in the bleak future--they can't just leave her there. It's cheap and would be the worst variation of what shall heretofore be known as "the Zach" (noun) or "Zaching (verb present)," or "to be Zached (verb past tense)."
The definition of the verb "to Zach" is, of course, the "Heroes" practice of dropping characters either without explaining their disappearance or, if their appearance is explained, it is forgotten and not mentioned again (Charlie became a victim of this type of "Zaching" during the feudal Japan storyline). Janice was nearly Zached until her appearance in the nightmare sequence. I think that Audrey has been effectively Zached. (wasn't Clea Duvall great?)

Caitlin is far too interesting and important a character to be "Zached." Not only is Carr a breath of fresh air, she is also a MUCH better love interest for Peter than Simone--a former series regular--ever was. She had better show up in Episode 11. If she is killed or stranded, she cannot be forgotten.

Anyway, I do have to talk about Mohinder. Attacking the character for his decision to spill the beans to Bob is unfair to the character, and I think a lot of it is rooted in his poor decisions of last season--we expect Mohinder to be "dumb as Mohinder," so we don't give him the benefit of the doubt and we're not willing to put ourselves in his situation.

I think it's pretty obvious that Bob is no Linderman, and he's certainly no Thompson. If he's "morally gray," he kind of reminds me of Noah for much of last season. Tobolowsky has been absolutely phenomenal in the role, and is easily the best of the new characters. I think it's obvious that the murder of Ivan was "morally un-gray" enough for Mohinder. He was even disturbed by the justifiable killing of Thompson. But what bothers me is Matt's long association with Noah--that MUST inform some of Mohinder's thinking. But I do think the murder of Ivan pushed him over the edge--and the fact that Bob has shown no signs of being another Thompson or Linderman. Couple this with the Noah/Mohinder phone conversation from earlier, though, and it's very understandable that Mohinder made this decision.

And how awful is it that the murder of Ivan was so totally useless, since he was discovered anyway? For me, this murder takes a lot of the shine off of Noah's supposed "reform." And he KNEW he was condemning his soul to hell. As a fan of the character, I really wish he had decided to leave Ivan alive.



Eric:

Otto -

Great review. According to Hiro, the real Kensei ripped his own heart out and gave it to the Dragon, thereby killing himself. Since this ended up not happening as history was changed, is this how Adam is alive in present-day seeking vengence? Is Adam an immortal who can also regenerate or is Claire immortal unless her heart is ripped out?

Secondly, what are your thoughts on the Special effects of Hiro teleporting? During the first season, the camera would close in on Hiro's scrunching face, then pan out to his new location. The effects of him just disappearing without the panning in-and-out ruins the "coolness".



Raissa:

KellyH,

Re: Noah -- I could be wrong. I was wrong last year when I thought Noah knew about Candaice-As-Sandra and was just playing along for his own reasons, which is why I haven't posted my S2 theory around...

What if Noah realizes that in order to get clear of the Company, he needs to take a page from his Claire-Bear's book: To escape death, you only have to die? What if this is all a fake out designed to make his family safer in the long run and it involves heavy risks:

1. The paintings -- Noah didn't know about the one predicting his death, but once he saw it and finished the natural freak out reaction, he decided to use the painting to his advantage, integrate it into the plan, and make the prophecy come true on his terms.

2. Ivan -- What if killing Ivan was always a secondary objective of the Ukraine visit? Noah knew his former employers would expect him to kill in cold blood, so he did. Noah knew that his death fake out and family escape needed Company witnesses, so he left his finger prints on purpose to make doubly sure even a Company rookie would get the hint.

3. Mohinder -- We don't actually know what "the plan" is? Perhaps, everything we've seen so far is the plan?

4. Claire/West -- If Claire is in on her father's fake out, it would help explain why she's kissing presumably West in the painting. Claire is playing along with West after he kills Noah, or she's thanking West for some other part he played (the prank?) after Mohinder kills Noah. What if the plan always was to get Claire noticed? "To escape death..."

5. Here's the kicker. Noah fakes his death by not faking it. There are spoilers regarding Claire's blood, which suggest they could go this route.
--------

Eric,

Adam cutting out his heart has already happened metaphorically with his quest for vengeance.



Otto:

Jay, Raissa, Daniel P, tree1138, I think we all agree this was the gem of the season so far.

Andrew -- word. The toxic twins (hah!) might be what drags next week's episode down. But if it covers the disaster that sent Maya and Alejandro on the run, it could be surprisingly good. We'll see.

With Kensei, I don't know if it would take centuries. I like the idea, but Claire was singed in "Company Man," and it didn't take her more than a couple of minutes to regenerate. I'm guessing the reason Hiro didn't find a skeleton next to Kensei's helmet was because Kensei had already healed and gone into hiding.

Raissa: "all [the episode] did was minimize the pre-existing story damage in context."

^ ^ I love how you phrased that! :)

It's sort of the point I've tried to make about the Kensei story; that if you take the last couple of episodes out of context, the story's conclusion was great; the problem is it's mired in such a weak set-up that it's difficult to only get absorbed at the end of it.

I'd still agree with KellyH's point: even if you compare this episode to last season's high points, it's one of the show's finest hours.

With Mohinder -- hee! 007 Mohinder ... Sorry. :)

I get what you're saying; I can let the confess-all moment slide because Mohinder's no double agent, and Mohinder's choice between an ostensibly well-intentioned company and a murderous wildcard wasn't a difficult choice.

Henrik, I agree about Maury's ability getting stronger the closer he is to the victim. Niki felt D.L. collapse into her arms, so the nightmares actually took physical form.

I'm glad you liked "HtSaEM." It was a great finale; it just wasn't spectacular, and I was expecting something spectacular, which is why it disappointed me. But a lot of people loved it, so you're definitely not in the minority. ;)

Daniel P: word on the Maya/Alejandro situation. Great characaters, weak story. Do you think the general feeling towards them will change after they get to New York and meet the rest of the characters?

Random thought: if Maya met the Haitian, would he block her ability? I mean, if the Haitian's power-blocker works on any mental ability, and if the black tears are triggered by agitation and a chain reaction in Maya's brain, would he be able to prevent her from killing everyone? Anyone have any idea?

I'm glad you liked the screencaps in the review. I'm hoping I'll be able to use them again. Heroes-pictures.com were cool with it, but our webmaster wasn't thrilled, and I can appreciate why, so we'll see. If I don't, please imagine the screencaps when I describe them! :)

But to answer your question, the reason the review was late was just overtime at my day job. Most of my reviews are written overnight, and that was impossible this week, hence the delay. I didn't think anyone would notice, but if your Thursday felt "empty" because of it, I'm extremely flattered.

Brandon: good catch with the mindreader "echo." I'm not sure; I think it could be like Sylar and Peter using the Eden-voice last season -- I think it was used for "coolness" rather than to suggest an explanation.

Do you think Peter will get to a stage where his mindreading develops the way Matt's and Maury's have? Will he start projecting thoughts into other people's heads and giving them nightmares?

Michael, I love your point about Maury scanning everyone's mind before he settled on Niki. I don't know why. It's like, [Scan], "Nah, that's a crap power," [Scan], "What am I supposed to do with THAT? You call that a superpower?" [Scan], "Yeah! Now THAT'S what I'm talkin' about!"

With Matt hunting down Maury: I think, given that Matt's a detective, and given that The Company's labs had CCTV, Matt could have been a little more proactive. He could have patrolled the building, he could have guarded Bob. That part seemed hazy to me.

Maury, though -- I agree he's in no way morally gray at the moment. But if the show did a flashback of the past 25 years and showed that he left his family to prevent tsunamis and use his ability as a form of therapy for people who were sick, I could definitely see him becoming a sympathetic character. The show likes to challenge our assumptions about characters, hence Noah and Sylar.

tree1138, good point about the "visit-the-future-then-prevent-it-from-happening" formula. I don't think it's been overused yet, but if they try it again, it's going to become that way.

With Caitlin, it's a bizarre headache. I mean, if the timeline is changed and the virus outbreak never happens, will Peter and Caitlin teleport to Times Square in 2008 and find it filled with people? And if the future is altered like that, will Peter still end up teleporting back to Montreal and partnering up with Adam? The whole fabric of the story comes undone.

I think Caitlin will be back.

KellyH, I totally agree about people writing off the start of the season as a sophomore slump. It's had a lot of strong moments, and I think it's going to be remembered very unfairly. I think what Kring mentioned a few times about fan expectations before the finale carried over into the new season: we expected something as mind-blowing as the final quarter of last season, and we didn't get it. But the past seven episodes have all had merits, even "Kindred."

"To be Zached." Hah! I like it.

I agree about ST playing Bob, and about Bob being one of the best characters. I wouldn't say he's the best; I'm waiting until we see more of David Anders playing Adam. I think he's going to own that role as well as Quinto owns Sylar.

Do you think Matt and Mohinder ever had a chance to compare notes? It could be that Mohinder left NY to go lecturing around the world almost immediately, which is why Matt never told him about Noah or Claire.

With Noah shooting Ivan: I see your point, but I think the whole "reformed" concept is what made Ivan's death so brilliantly written. I mean, Noah can't be reformed. The whole Company mindset is ingrained in him; the whole Company ethos -- vicious actions to achieve a "worthy" goal -- is second nature to him. I think it's part of what makes Noah such a compelling character.

Eric, I don't know about the regeneration/immortality. Will Claire get to adulthood and then stop ageing? My guess was always that Kensei's immortality was a separate ability to regeneration, but you could probably take a scientific stance and argue that at a certain point, when the cells in your body would usually begin to deteriorate, anyone who can regenerate just goes on and on and on. I don't know.

With the teleportation, I guess it's kind of cheap. It doesn't bother me too much because the ability itself is still so cool. But compared with the "melting" effect when Hiro teleported back to the subway in "Don't Look Back," it's definitely been simplified.



Daniel P:

I'm not sure, because after what can be considered a very bland introduction, it'll be hard for people to completely accept the two. Although, D.L. certainly gained some love after killing off Linderman.

I think that is what would happen, but I doubt they'll ever cross paths.

Well, here's hoping we'll see them again.

Maybe not "empty", per se, but since your reviews are always interesting to read, they were missed.



Susan:

Otto,

Finally, your review is up!

I'm sorry real life got in the way of posting this, but that happens to everybody ... eventually. The problem with this getting posted so late is my real life gets in the way of me being able to read it as soon as I'd like.

I've really been looking forward to your review because the episode was just so exciting. It was very promising and gives me hope for the rest of the season.

Random thoughts on your review ...

And, yes, I know that's longer than the usual overview. Sue me. A lot happened in this episode.

I think that's a key point ... a lot happened. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said about the previous seven.

Maybe Kring had a harder time letting go of his concept of season 2 being about totally new characters than he realized or acknowledged.

As for the CGI, what is the difference? Why is it so bad one week and amazing the next? Who is to blame? The director ... editor ... Kring ... the company responsible for creating the effects?

I'm not even sure Noah trusts the Haitian. As far as we know, there still hasn't been a serious conversation about the whole reporting-to-Mrs.-Petrelli-over-Noah's-head issue.

Couldn't that be a bit of a non-issue since it all comes back to protecting Claire?

More obviously, it's an enormous obstacle when it comes to introducing new characters, especially when the biggest complaint from fans about the new season is that it spends too much time with new characters whose stories have failed to captivate the audience the way the original characters' storylines managed to last season.

The show took a misstep in how they introduced some of the new characters. Maya and Alejandro's introduction was terribly redundant and what was worse nothing really seemed to happen. As for West, it amazes me that the writers thought it would be a good idea to have this guy watching Claire through windows. If nothing else, they should have set it up differently ... give him a reason for being there.

Kring mentioned that they thought the viewers wanted a slow build up like last season. Problem is there's a big difference between that and stagnating (which the first part of this season seemed to do).



Susan:

Part 2 - The Petrellis

I like the points you made about Nathan and him picking up on the way Bob said things.

As for Peter electrifying the CDC workers, what would water do to someone with electrical powers?

I'll sound like a broken record if I say it again, but I really, really wish a volume with the title "GENERATIONS," a volume which was supposedly going to involve the sins of the parents being revisited on the children, could give this backstory a little more detail. The Shanti Virus is obviously a key part of it, but I can't help thinking that the whole story deserves more attention than it's getting.

I totally agree. What's the possibility of Volume 3 being titled "The Elders"? Or maybe they should have waited to introduce some of these new characters until Volume 3, so they could have focused more on the early details of the ElderSupers.

Beeman? Kring? You guys still listening to fans complaining? I want you to ask yourself whether the drama from these characters and this story wouldn't have been about fifty trillion times more compelling than a super who cries black goo, a b**chy cheerleader who gets her comeuppance, and a princess in feudal Japan who paints purple flags. Because, good God.

Here, here! (Or is it "Hear, hear"?)

Let me get this straight: Bob knew Peter was alive and Angela didn't? What happened? Did Bob expel her from the inner circle after Linderman died? Is she totally out of the loop when it comes to Company operations?

Or maybe she is in on the whole thing? (Which actually even I doubt that. She was too convincing as a grieving mother.) Or all the Elders are doing something behind the backs of the others?

Cristine Rose needs an Emmy.

As I said, this episode got my hopes up that the season will be picking up. Bring on "Four Months Ago"! (It was written by Kring, right? So it should at least be decent ... I hope.)



Wings4Music:

Seriously, I'm the only one of my friends who feels like there's more to West--I just can't stand him! And I'm always right when it comes to characters, and that one I do not trust. Can't stand West, but Adam Monroe has so much charisma, and the actor is obviously talented, so even though he's the bad guy I hope he sticks around for a long time...I was afraid the 'virus' storyline would be boring and predictable, due to it looking like last season's storyline, but it was made to be even more intriguing and have more effects that it made me go 'this is the Heroes I know and love!'

Definitely the best of the season, and my fave B/C Mama Petrilli said Peter was the "'most powerful of us all.'" Hiro has not ceased to annoy me since the season premiere, and Claire keeps making me roll my eyes, and the Nikki and Nathan moment definitely killed me...if I have to lose one half of the Petrilli-brothers...Anyway, the review was mostly on point, and thankfully the show is going somewhere now.



Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Heroes and its characters and related images are copyright ©2007 NBC Universal Television. This is a fan site and not authorized by NBC. Page copyright ©2007 KryptonSite, unless the material is noted as coming from someplace else or being by an individual author.

Heroes stars Hayden Panettiere, Jack Coleman, Tawny Cypress, Leonard Roberts, Santiago Cabrera, Masi Oka, Greg Grunberg, Adrian Pasdar, Milo Ventimiglia, Ali Larter, Noah Grey-Cabey, and Sendhil Ramamurthy.

PLEASE DO NOT TAKE GRAPHICS, NEWS, SPOILERS, ETC. FROM HEROSITE WITHOUT FIRST ASKING PERMISSION AND PLACING A LINK TO HEROSITE.NET. OR, JUST SEND PEOPLE OVER TO THIS SITE! THANKS!